Humans evolved to seek out the warmth and reciprocity of the small groups we depended on for our survival. Yet many contemporary organisations are cold, impersonal and profoundly unequal, just as many cities are designed in ways that leave people feeling alienated and out of place.
Here I argue that just as our innate ‘biophilia’, our attraction to life in all its forms, explains why we feel at home in particular kinds of physical landscape but not in others, 'sociophilia', our attraction to groups, explains why we feel at home in particular kinds of social landscape but not in others.
Better understanding of biophilia has helped to guide urban planning to make cities greener, less rigid and more alive. In a similar way, taking sociophilia seriously opens up new options for the design of organisations, services and technologies, as well as throwing up new challenges as we try to combine efficiency and scale on the one hand, with warmth and humanity on the other.
Biophilia: why some places feel like home
Humans were shaped by evolution to survive in often hostile and dangerous environments. As a result, we are drawn to the things that help us survive and thrive, and many of these come from the natural world. The psychologist Erich Fromm coined the term 'biophilia', literally love of life, to describe this. A few years later the biologist E.O. Wilson developed and popularised the idea, arguing that we all have an "innate tendency to focus on life and lifelike processes" and that, as living beings, we are naturally attracted to other living things, whether plants, pets or people, and their presence helps us to thrive.
Wilson showed that this innate biophilia helps to explain why we feel at home in landscapes that echo the African savannahs where early humans evolved. We particularly like trees combined with open grassland, plenty of light, water and green surroundings, and this is what people try to recreate in their gardens and parks in every corner of the world, from China to Canada, India to Scotland.
Once you understand this innate biophilia it becomes obvious why a walk in a park or a forest can be so therapeutic. It also becomes obvious why we don't feel so at home in the opposite kind of place: ones that are rigid, grey, boxy, windswept and empty, with no greenery and no water to catch the light. Some people have had little choice, living in deserts or tundra. And a minority love glass towers, brutalist buildings and concrete jungles. But most people, given the choice, opt for places that are much more obviously in sync with biophilia.
Yet a remarkably high proportion of modern places are anti-biophilic. They almost seem designed to make us feel alienated, anxious and out of place. Much 20th-century architecture simply ignored our preferences, opting instead for machine-like regularity, superhuman scale and grey surfaces, covering the planet with places that feel neither alive nor welcoming.
There’s a subtler aspect to this too. Most people love the fractal shapes common in nature – the repeating, branching and subtly variegated patterns of leaves, trees, clouds and mountains. But many cities provided the opposite: precisely repetitive squares and rectangles. Compare a town of red roofs that are similar but each subtly different, as in many Italian towns, with a housing estate of identical square blocks. The first appeals instantly; the second is instantly off-putting.
From biophilia to sociophilia
I think there is a precisely comparable pattern in our social lives and organisations, best called ‘sociophilia’, love of the social. Sociophilia is our innate attraction to social environments that echo the conditions in which humans evolved: small groups full of care, love, humour, and belonging, groups in which we are surrounded by people who know us well and which are founded on reciprocity – relationships of give and take, which put us at ease in a way that neither domination nor servility does.
Just as innate biophilia explains why we don’t feel at home in certain environments, so does innate sociophilia explain why we don't thrive in environments made up of large impersonal organisations, cold bureaucracies and unfeeling corporations.
The pull of sociophilia explains many everyday patterns. You can see it in workplaces where people try to recreate the intimacy of the small group (and even in the meeting rules of companies like Amazon that try to keep them to a maximum of six, or two pizzas). You can see something similar in the appeal of local shops, pubs, cafes and charities. You can see it in universities based on colleges that are aiming at more human scale units of belonging. And you can see the same dynamic in armies and in the abundant evidence that soldiers tend to care most about their immediate group, and are more willing to sacrifice themselves for their comrades than for the army or the nation.
But just as our built environments can systematically alienate us, so can the organisations around us do the same. Many of the institutions that shape our lives are anything but aligned with sociophilia: economies run by distant oligarchs, faceless utilities, call centres with formulaic scripts, large public bureaucracies that treat us just as a number or a category. This alienation is hard to measure, but it is clearly there.
Failure to understand this explains much of what went wrong with socialism and communism. Their appeal fed off sociophilia, the hunger for equity, reciprocity and groups without sharp divides and hierarchies. But the forms they took in the 20th century ended up with an opposite ethos, too often impersonal, oppressive, distant.
Identity
Sociophilia helps to explain one of the most consistent findings of psychology: our extraordinary propensity to identify with a ‘we’, and against a ‘they’. This has been shown again and again in experiments – how quickly we come to identify with a group, however tenuously based, and switch into hostility to others. This is clearly a deeply rooted tendency of all humans and is easily explained in terms of our evolutionary background. It makes us identify with religions, ethnicities, nations, football teams, the fan clubs of music stars and pretty much anything else that offers us some belonging. It helps to explain the passions of warfare, or of red v blue.
Many of these identities are much larger than the small group. If you identify as Hindu, MAGA or deep ecology you’re part of a vast group of strangers most of whom you’ll never meet. But part of the appeal of even the largest groups is that they offer a hint of the warmth of the small group, a sense that we matter and that we belong.
Yet this is also of course their problem: the very drives that encourage us to bond and belong also encourage us to divide, to become chauvinist, tribal, ‘my country right or wrong’: hence the need for at least some universals to balance the particulars.
The porcupine problem
Sociophilia is not always straightforward in other ways too. The small group can be a nightmare. Some of us are driven mad by the intimacy of the family or the small community, where we are known too well and our every move is watched. Hence the appeal of the anonymity of the big city, or of the corporation or official who knows little about our lives.
The philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer captured this well with his image of porcupines in winter. They huddle together for warmth but are pushed apart by each other's spines, always seeking the right balance between closeness and distance. We are much the same. What we need is not intimacy everywhere, but the right balance in the right places.
Warm surfaces, efficient foundations
What follows for social design? There are good reasons to remake our cities to align better with biophilia – filling them with living things, fractal shapes, trees and water – and there is strong evidence that this makes us happier.
But we should also want to remake our societies and organisations to align better with sociophilia. That means designing the surfaces of organisations – their 'front ends', where people actually encounter them – to be more cellular, warmer, more loving and more human in scale.
These principles run counter to the ones that have dominated business and government for at least a century using standardisation, scale, efficiency and frictionless interactions, all promising economies of scale and scope (UK government, for example, periodically convinces itself to consolidate units at much larger scale despite the absence of any evidence that this leads to better results). The TV programme ‘Undercover Boss’, in which CEOs went undercover to spend time on the frontline of their own organisations, only worked because so few people have any idea what their bosses look like.
My hunch is that we shouldn't see efficiency and humanity as a binary choice. The challenge is to find combinations that get the best of both. In practice, that may mean underlying systems that deliver scale, standardisation and efficiency – rather than reinvention, duplication and waste – which is just what digital tools, the internet and AI can offer, as do the multitude of rules and regulations needed to promote safety in everything from food to cars to medicines.
But on top of these we need services and surfaces that embody reciprocity. We already see glimpses of this in the gym chain with personal trainers, the NHS with its GPs, the big firm with coaches and mentors, or the Internet with its myriad social connections.
Getting the balance right can be tricky. Some services should be as simple, frictionless and automatic as possible; others should be much more relational (I set out this spectrum in work on the 'relational state' at the Young Foundation nearly 20 years ago suggesting why we might want something like paying taxes to be as impersonal as possible, whereas care should be highly relational).
But my hope is that the sociophilia lens opens up productive questions. What would a care service designed around sociophilia look like? Or a school accountable to parents? A park owned by local residents? A pub its regulars can become members of? And what might their foundations be – standardising what’s best standardised so that the human parts of a service can be fully human?
The problem with simulated warmth
These questions are in part about design. But they are also about who owns and controls our institutions and here we hit a problem, one that is particularly stark with AI. Many businesses already offer a simulation of sociophilia. Capitalism in its mass-consumer phase delivered huge gains in productivity, efficiency and frictionless service, as well as sometimes showing a very human face with staff rigorously trained to smile and be helpful.
Services for the wealthy show this ambiguity in extreme form. They look at first glance very sociophiliac: private clubs, concierges, coaches, therapists and curated boutique hotels all offer the warmth of the small group, in contrast to mass consumerism. They provide a wonderful feeling of care and attention (and the very rich surround themselves with an entourage that mimics the small groups of human prehistory).
But even the best services that mimic sociophilia have a dishonesty at their core. They look like a friend. Yet they are an imitation, not the real thing. If their first loyalty lies elsewhere – with their owners – then at crucial moments they are bound to let us down.
This is even more true of AI. Generative AI is brilliant at mimicking human warmth: it can play the part of a friend, coach, colleague or confidant. But the operative word is 'play'. If the companies behind AI answer first to their owners – and perhaps, through them, to superpower governments – then at some point we will be let down. Our interests will certainly not be paramount. There is the appearance of reciprocity, but not the reality.
Sociophilia and power
In short, sociophilia offers pointers for designing the surfaces of organisations and technologies. But it also highlights the need for power structures that are more distributed, shared and open, with genuine reciprocity rather than a fake version.
At present, the emerging 21st-century economy is heading the other way. A healthy society and economy has a plurality of forms of ownership. But ours is now far too uniform: a monoculture dominated by impersonal states and by a handful of big, shareholder-owned and oligarch-run companies, many of them based in California. Its concentrations of power are now having ugly effects, not least as billionaire oligarchs intervene in politics or spread misinformation that is clearly against the interests of their consumers.
Unless that changes, it is bound to bring alienation. But when the backlash happens, let’s hope that it favours both biophilia and sociophilia which provide guides to the physical and social homes in which we are most likely to thrive.